Close this search box.
Home / Articles / Defined Contribution Plans vs. Defined Benefit Plans 2013

Defined Contribution Plans vs. Defined Benefit Plans 2013

August 15, 2013


Which option is right for your business?

What is the best retirement plan for your business? The answer depends on several factors, including the ages of owners and employees, the number of years to retirement and more. This article explains some of the options available and how they can benefit you and your business from a tax-savings standpoint.

Have you procrastinated in setting up a tax-advantaged retirement plan for your business? If the answer is yes, you’re not alone. Still, not having a plan in place hurts you and your business. Why? You’re paying more income taxes every year than necessary — money that could be used for better purposes.

However, you still have time to set things right and line yourself up for major tax savings for this year and beyond. This article explains the basics of tax-advantaged retirement plans, which are now better than ever thanks to changes in the tax law that permit larger annual deductible contributions. Once you cut through all the technical details, you’ll discover that tax-advantaged retirement plans come in two basic varieties:

1. Defined contribution plans (which, as you will see, come in several varieties themselves).
2. Defined benefit pension plans (which only come in one variety).

Defined Contribution Plans: With these plans, annual deductible contributions are made to your account. The maximum annual contribution amount is specified by the tax law (usually with annual inflation adjustments). For small businesses, contributions are generally discretionary, which means you don’t need to contribute anything in years when cash is tight.

Your account balance at retirement age will depend on:

• How soon you begin contributing.
• How much you contribute.
• The rate of return earned on investments held in your account.

The sooner you start contributing, the sooner you’ll start reaping annual tax savings. Your account’s earnings are allowed to accumulate tax-free until you begin taking withdrawals. Even better, there’s no limit on how much can be accumulated in your account. Defined contribution plans include defined contribution Keogh plans, corporate profit-sharing plans, and simplified employee pensions (SEPs).

Some defined contribution plans allow so-called salary reduction or elective deferral contributions, which come out of your salary (or are deemed to come from your salary if you are self-employed). These plans also allow additional contributions to be made by your employer (or deemed to be made by the employer if you are self-employed). Salary reduction arrangements include 401(k) plans and SIMPLE plans. In any case, the distinguishing feature of a defined contribution plan is the maximum amount that can be contributed to your account each year. It is calculated based on a percentage of your compensation or self-employment income for that year — subject to an annual maximum contribution limit. The limit for 2013 is:

• $51,000 — or $56,500 for a 401(k) plan if you are 50 or older as of December 31, 2013.
• $11,500 for a SIMPLE plan.

Defined Benefit Plans: With this plan, contributions to your account are based on what is needed to fund a promised “target” level of annual payments after you reach retirement age. The annual benefit is usually based on a percentage of earnings during your last few years of work. You (if you’re self-employed) or your company (if employed by your own corporation) makes annual deductible contributions to your account in amounts sufficient to fund the promised level of retirement-age payouts.

Contribution amounts must be calculated by an actuary based on:

•Your remaining number of years to retirement.
•The expected rate of return on investments held in your account.
•The promised level of annual benefits.
•Your current account balance.

Here’s the key selling point: Very large annual contributions are required to adequately fund your defined benefit account if you are a high earner and relatively close to retirement age. In this scenario, you have only a few years left to build up an account balance big enough to deliver the promised hefty level of annual post-retirement payouts. Large annual contributions translate into large annual deductions, which in turn translate into large annual tax savings for you.

For 2013, a defined benefit plan cannot specify a target annual payout in excess of $205,000. This limit is adjusted annually for inflation. If you run your business as a sole proprietorship or single-member LLC, a defined benefit arrangement takes the form of a Keogh defined benefit pension plan. If you’re employed by your own S or C corporation, the company establishes a corporate defined benefit pension plan on your behalf. For high earners, age 50 or over, with plenty of available cash, the defined benefit pension plan may be the best choice. However, a defined benefit arrangement is generally more expensive to establish and operate than other alternatives.

Another negative: You’re locked into mandatory annual contributions until your account becomes fully funded. For these reasons, you should strongly consider the 401(k) plan option, which also permits larger annual deductible contributions for those age 50 and older. Now you see the basics of defined contribution plans and defined benefit pension plans and how they can help fund your retirement.

Retirement Plans Are Multi-Faceted

Starting a retirement plan is important for at least three reasons:

  1. Your retirement plan is a key factor in your ability to retire well at the age of your choice.
  2. It is a smart way to reduce your tax bill.
  3. It can be a significant recruiting and retention tool when hiring employees. This is especially true of defined contribution plans, which often include employer-matching and tax-deferred savings benefits.

Bill Edwards is the Shareholder-in-Charge of the Qualified Plan Administration and Consulting Group at Clark Schaefer Hackett, and a member of the firm’s Professional Services Provider Industry Group. He can be reached at 937.399.2000 or [email protected].

Candice DeClark is the Chair of the Professional Services Group and can be reached at [email protected] or at 937.399.2000.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a Clark Schaefer Hackett professional. Clark Schaefer Hackett will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.


Related Articles


2 Min Read

ESOP evaluation from a succession planning perspective


2 Min Read

Proposed regulations for inherited IRAs bring unwelcome surprises


2 Min Read

Time to Increase Your Internal Audit Awareness


2 Min Read

Preparing for New Employee Benefit Plans Audit Standard


2 Min Read

New Audit Standard for Employee Benefit Plans: What You Need to Know


2 Min Read

Top Ten Strategies for End of Year Planning

Get in Touch.

What service are you looking for? We'll match you with an experienced advisor, who will help you find an effective and sustainable solution.

  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.