Skip to main content
Share this
Protecting Your Not-for-Profit's Property Tax Exemption

Protecting Your Not-for-Profit's Property Tax Exemption

A lot of not-for-profit leaders assume that once the IRS grants 501(c)(3) status, property tax exemption follows automatically. It doesn't. Exemption is a separate determination made at the state or local level, and cash-strapped municipalities have grown more willing to challenge it, particularly for larger organizations like hospitals and universities with substantial real estate holdings.

Two Different Governments, Two Different Tests

Every state often exempts some or all charitable not-for-profit property from taxation, but a federal exemption letter alone doesn't automatically qualify a property for it. Organizations typically have to apply separately with a county or local assessor, demonstrate the property is used for an exempt purpose, and in many states, requalify periodically rather than receiving a one-time determination that lasts forever. Requirements vary widely: some states ask for an annual report, others reassess every few years. When a challenge does arise, the burden of proof generally falls on the organization, not the local government, to show the exemption is still warranted.

The Pattern Behind Recent Challenges

The organizations that end up in disputes tend to share a pattern: their operations look, on paper, more like a business than a charity. Courts and assessors have scrutinized fee-based programs that resemble commercial pricing, corporate structures that mix not-for-profit and for-profit affiliates, and executive or physician compensation tied to profit metrics.

These disputes often hinge on details that appeared minor until scrutinized. A fee structure that looks commercial on paper, the precise wording of a legislative exemption, or how a building is actually used day to day can all become the deciding factor once a challenge is underway. Even a long-standing exemption isn't immune: an organization that has operated the same way for years can still lose ground if an assessor or court takes a closer look and finds the operational reality doesn't line up with the exemption's original terms.

Building the Record Before You Need It

Because the burden of proof rests with the organization, the best defense is established well before a challenge arises. This means maintaining documentation that connects each property’s use to the organization’s exempt purpose, substantiates charity care or reduced-cost services, and clearly defines the structure of for-profit affiliates and compensation arrangements. Organizations that address these matters only after a challenge arises enter the process from a significantly weaker position.

Not every not-for-profit should expect a challenge. But the trend is toward more scrutiny, and organizations with significant real estate or revenue-generating activities are the ones most likely to draw attention first.

Where to Get Ahead of This

Reviewing exemption filings and shoring up documentation before an assessor or a court raises questions is exactly the kind of work CSH's State & Local Tax team does regularly with not-for-profit clients.

Ready to talk through your organization's property tax exemption position? Connect with a CSH advisor today to start the conversation.

Sherry Henning

Director
As Controller for CSH’s Managed Services team, Sherry is responsible for providing their clients with experience, advisory services, analysis, budget, audit, and ongoing financial reporting.
You may also like

Contact Us